The Podcaster Plus Show

17 – Using AI to Create Podcast Content: Is This a Good Idea?

Released

Episode # 17

Welcome to another episode of Podcaster Plus!

This time, host Nathan Wrigley takes us on an exploration of one of the most talked-about trends in podcasting today: using AI to create your show’s content.

With artificial intelligence tools like Jasper, Copy AI, and Google’s NotebookLM promising greater efficiency and faster content creation, it can be incredibly tempting for busy podcasters to hand over the creative reins.But is relying on AI really the best move for your podcast in the long run?

In this episode, Nathan unpacks the potential pitfalls of using AI as your main content creator.

He discusses the risks of ending up with bland, generic episodes that lack originality and a distinctive voice, the danger of spreading inaccuracies or ethical missteps, and the possibility of stifling your own growth as a creator.

On the flip side, he acknowledges where AI truly shines, as a brainstorming partner, for rapid outlining, or transcribing interviews.

He also delivers some tips for podcasters who want to get the most out of AI without sacrificing the personality and authenticity that makes their show stand out.

Whether you’re curious, skeptical, or already experimenting with AI, this episode offers advice on embracing these new tools while always keeping your unique voice at the heart of your podcast.

Remember to check out the show notes for the links to resources mentioned in this episode at podcasterplus.com/show. And we will see you next time for some more tips and tricks to simplify and automate your podcast.

Resources:

Omniscient Digital: 5 Pitfalls of AI-Generated Content

Descript: How to Write a Podcast Script: Step-by-Step in 2025

Key topics:

Introduction to the Episode

  • Presentation of the episode’s main question: Is using AI to create podcast content a good idea?
  • Explanation of the episode’s structure (broken into sections).

The Allure of AI

  • Efficiency: AI tools promise to speed up the workflow.
  • Overcoming creative blocks: Help with idea generation and scriptwriting.
  • Examples of AI platforms: Jasper, Copy AI, Google’s Notebook LM.
  • Continuous availability: AI operates 24/7, unlike human collaborators.

The Case Against AI-Generated Podcasts

  • Lack of originality and creativity: AI content tends to be generic, repetitive, and lacking in unique insight.
  • Absence of a distinct voice: AI cannot replicate the personal tone and touch of a human host.
  • Potential for inaccuracies and ethical issues:
    • Risk of incorrect information and plagiarism.
    • Possibility of generating biased or offensive material.
    • Need for human oversight to fact-check and maintain ethical standards.
  • Risk of stifling creativity: Overreliance on AI can prevent personal growth and development of a unique podcast style.

AI as a Tool, Not a Replacement

  • AI’s positive role as a support mechanism:
    • Brainstorming ideas.
    • Generating initial drafts.
    • Transcribing interviews.
  • Importance of human oversight to ensure quality, authenticity, and originality.
  • Encouragement to use AI to enhance, not substitute, human creativity.

Practical Tips for Using AI in Podcasting

  • Set clear guidelines for the AI’s output.
  • Review and edit content meticulously, including thorough fact-checking.
  • Infuse personal personality into the content with anecdotes and opinions.
  • Assign AI to specific, suitable tasks (brainstorming, outlining, transcription) rather than full script generation.

Conclusion

  • Summary: AI can offer useful shortcuts, but shouldn’t be the sole creator.
  • Human creativity and voice are essential for engaging, memorable podcasts.
  • Final encouragement to use AI strategically while prioritizing originality.
  • Reminder to check show notes for resources.
  • Sign-off and teaser for future episodes.
Transcript

Hello there and welcome to Podcaster Plus. The podcast offering tips and tricks to simplify and automate your podcast. Find all the episodes at podcasterplus.com/show.

Today we’re tackling a hot topic, using AI to create podcast content. Many people, hmm let’s be honest, all of us, are exploring AI tools to streamline their workflow. But is this truly a beneficial approach, or are there significant drawbacks to consider?

In this episode, we’ll delve into the arguments against using AI as your primary content creation tool for your podcast.

As always, we’re gonna chunk this episode into various different sections.

And the first section is the allure of AI. Let’s be clear AI tools offer undeniable appeal. They promise increased efficiency, the ability to generate content quickly, and potentially even overcome writer’s block. Platforms like Jasper, Copy AI, and even Google’s Notebook LM offer features that seem incredibly tempting for busy podcasters. They can generate scripts, outlines, and even interview questions, seemingly saving you hours of work. The 24 7 availability of these tools is also a significant draw, allowing for continuous content creation without the limitation of human schedules.

Section two, the case against AI generated podcasts. The convenience of AI though comes with significant caveats. The most critical issue is the lack of originality and creativity. AI models are trained on existing data, meaning the output often mirrors existing themes, phrases, and ideas. This results in generic formulaic and repetitive content that lacks the unique insights and innovative perspectives that human writers bring. Your podcast needs to stand out, and AI generated content struggles to achieve this. It simply doesn’t offer the fresh perspectives and unique angles that a human host can provide.

Furthermore, AI generated content lacks a distinct voice. Whilst human writers have unique tones, perspectives and personalities that resonate with listeners, AI produces content based on templates, lacking the personal touch that fosters a strong connection with your audience. Your podcast personality is a key element of its success, and AI can’t replicate that.

Another significant concern is the potential for factual inaccuracies and ethical issues. While AI tools are improving, they’re not infallible. They can generate incorrect information, plagiarized content, or even produce biased or offensive material. This requires meticulous fact checking and editing, negating some of the time saving benefits. The responsibility for ensuring accuracy and ethical standards remains firmly with the podcaster, even when using AI tools.

Finally over reliance on AI can stifle your own creativity and growth as a podcaster. While AI can assist in the process, it shouldn’t replace your own unique insights, experiences, and storytelling abilities. Using AI as a crutch can prevent you from developing your own style and voice, ultimately hindering your podcast’s long-term success.

The next section then is AI as a tool, not a replacement. So all of this doesn’t mean that AI is entirely useless for podcasters. It can be a valuable tool for brainstorming ideas, generating initial drafts, or even transcribing interviews. However, it’s crucial to use AI strategically, viewing it as a support system, rather than as a replacement for your own creative input. Human oversight is essential to ensure accuracy, originality, and authenticity. The best approach is to use AI to enhance your workflow, not replace your role as the creative force behind your podcast.

Okay, next section, practical tips for using AI. If you choose to incorporate AI into your podcast creation process, here are some practical tips.

The first one, set clear guidelines. Provide specific instructions and examples to guide the AI’s output.

Also review and edit meticulously. Fact check all information and ensure the content aligns with your brand’s voice and values.

Next, infuse your personality. Add personal anecdotes, insights, and experiences to make your content truly your own.

And use AI for specific tasks. Focus on using AI for tasks like brainstorming, outlining, or transcription, rather than relying on it to generate entire scripts.

So to conclude, while AI offers tempting shortcuts, relying solely on it to create podcast content is not really a recipe for success. The lack of originality, voice, and potential for inaccuracies sometimes can outweigh the benefits of increased efficiency.

AI can definitely be a valuable tool, but it should never replace the human element that makes a podcast truly engaging and memorable. Embrace AI strategically, but always prioritize your own creative vision and authentic voice.

So there you go. That’s what I’ve got for you this time around. Thank you very much for tuning into the Podcaster Plus Podcast.

Remember to check out the show notes for the links to resources mentioned in this episode at podcasterplus.com/show. And we will see you next time for some more tips and tricks to simplify and automate your podcast. 

Introducing Podcaster Plus!

Effortlessly create stunning, fully customisable podcast pages with the Podcaster Plus WordPress plugin. Build your ideal podcast site in just a few clicks.